Family Trauma and the Hidden Costs of People Pleasing

Family Trauma and the Hidden Costs of People Pleasing

Late December is a time of year when people spend more time with family. Christmas and other significant family events can bring up unfinished business and family trauma from years past. Most people associate family gatherings with the joy of connection, familiarity, and belonging. But whenever families come together for weddings, birthdays, funerals, or religious festivals, there is also a risk of reopening old wounds.

The family dramas we see portrayed in comedies are often played for laughs. In real life, family conflict can be devastating. For those who grew up in families where parents were emotionally inconsistent, unresponsive, or unavailable, these occasions can feel more like emotional endurance tests than celebrations. For many, this is family trauma in adulthood.

Contact me now for an initial appointment


When Family Gatherings Reopen Old Wounds

We do not choose our parents or our siblings. Long-standing resentments, jealousies, exclusions, and unspoken rules can extinguish the joy of seeing relatives. When our family does not recognise our adult selves, it can feel deeply dismissive, as though the person we have worked hard to become is invisible.

Reclaiming access to one’s authentic self often takes time and effort. Sometimes this work follows childhood bullying or abuse that shut parts of us down. For others, it is about core aspects of identity such as sexuality, gender, or values that were never welcomed or supported.

Christmas stress can intensify family trauma. There is often an unspoken expectation that family members will simply endure discomfort for the sake of harmony. The message is that individual pain should be swallowed, managed quietly, or performed away with a smile. This performative response denies the reality of emotional injury and loneliness.

Family events are not fun or happy occasions for everyone. For some, they are reminders of past trauma, attended out of obligation or necessity, dates of dread we wish were already over.

Family Trauma and the Fawn Response: People Pleasing and Emotional Labour

Family Trauma and the Fawn Response: People Pleasing and Emotional Labour

People pleasing is often misunderstood as a personality trait or a lack of assertiveness. In reality, it can be an automatic response to stress. Alongside fight, flight, and freeze, there is a fourth response: fawn.

The fawn response develops when safety depends on appeasing others. It can keep distress out of sight, even from yourself. It makes emotional harm look like coping and conceals the pain you are in. Many people who grew up navigating parental expectations, criticism, or emotional volatility learned that staying agreeable was the safest option.

At family gatherings, this can show up as excessive emotional labour. Managing other people’s feelings. Smoothing over tension. Absorbing criticism. Avoiding conflict at personal cost. Over time, this erodes trust in your own emotional signals and deepens internalised shame.

Find out about therapy session availability


Family Trauma, Attachment, and Internalised Shame

Family trauma often shapes attachment patterns. Anxious and avoidant attachment are not flaws. They are adaptations.

People with anxious attachment frequently grew up in environments where care was inconsistent. Love may have felt conditional or unpredictable. As adults, this can show up as hypervigilance, people pleasing, fear of rejection, and a heightened sensitivity to exclusion, especially within family systems.

Those with avoidant attachment often learned early that emotional needs would not be met. Dependence felt risky. Self-reliance became a form of protection. In family settings, this can look like emotional withdrawal, minimising one’s needs, or staying physically present while remaining emotionally distant.

Both patterns are linked to internalised shame. When a child’s needs are repeatedly unmet or criticised, the conclusion is often not “this environment is unsafe” but “something is wrong with me.” This shame can persist well into adulthood, particularly when family dynamics continue to reinforce it.

For some, this internal distress leads to searching for explanations through diagnoses. Anxiety born from family conflict can be mistaken for ADHD. Obsessive or rigid thinking can be labelled as OCD, when it is better understood as a response to chronic dysregulation in childhood. These experiences are not signs of brokenness, but understandable responses to relational stress.

Family Trauma, Attachment, and Internalised Shame

Betrayal, Estrangement, and the Loneliness of Exclusion

Betrayal within a family takes many forms. It can be overt, such as exclusion, isolation, or abuse. It can also be subtle, through gaslighting, stonewalling, or being made responsible for an unfair emotional burden.

Betrayal is especially damaging when it occurs in a family of origin. Family is where we first learn whether the world is safe and whether we are welcome in it. When trust is broken there, the injury cuts deeply. Many adult survivors of childhood neglect or emotional unavailability carry a quiet belief that they were somehow wrong.

In some families, religion takes priority over connection. I have worked with many people who are survivors of religious trauma, where parents placed their relationship with God, doctrine, or community above their relationship with their child. In more extreme cases, such as cult-like environments, family members are trained to sever emotional bonds in the name of belief.

Estrangement is often framed as selfish or unforgiving. In reality, it is frequently an act of self-preservation. The loneliness of exclusion can be painful, but it can also be a signal that something in the relationship was deeply unsafe.


Your Emotions Are There to Help You

Guilt does not always mean you have done something wrong. Sometimes guilt is a sign that you are finally taking care of yourself. Anger tells you your boundaries have been crossed. Sadness tells you you have lost something of value. Shame tells you that you fear rejection. Loneliness tells you that you deserve connection.

These emotions carry useful information. Yet at family events, especially when alcohol or other substances (drugs) are involved, people often feel pressured to override them. Alcohol is a disinhibitor, and sometimes inhibitions are protective. I recommend that people do not put themselves in harm’s way, emotionally or physically, simply to meet family expectations.

Walking on eggshells, bracing for ridicule, or fearing public shaming are not signs of resilience. They are signs of unresolved family trauma.

Book a telehealth or in-person appointment now


Healing Family Trauma Through Self-Compassion and Self-Trust

Healing Family Trauma Through Self-Compassion and Self-Trust

Healing begins with safety. Stepping back from toxic relationships can be part of that process. Healing from trauma is not about pushing through or revisiting painful experiences before you are ready. Organisations such as Blue Knot emphasise the importance of safety, stabilisation, and nervous system regulation before working through past trauma.

If there is a trauma bond with a family member, remaining in close contact before you feel internally safe may hinder recovery rather than support it.

Healing after betrayal is about restoring trust in yourself. This work does not start with reconciliation. It starts with self-compassion. Above all, it is about not abandoning yourself.

Pop psychology often focuses on the inner child or the inner critic. Less attention is given to the idea of an inner parent or inner cheerleader. I encourage people to cultivate internal voices that are steady, encouraging, and authoritative in a nurturing way. Tuning into supportive inner voices is often more healing than repeatedly revisiting wounds.

Even if your childhood was marked by emotional distance or criticism, you do not need to be emotionally distant from yourself now.


How Forward Therapy Helps

One of my roles is to help people trust themselves again. That includes backing your own perceptions, emotions, and needs. Rejection is not evidence of your deficits. It often reveals the limitations of the systems or relationships you are in.

My work is relational rather than pathologising. I am less interested in what is “wrong” with a person and more interested in how they were shaped by how they were received. If you grew up without adequate support, hypervigilance and anxiety make sense.

Through self-compassion, nervous system regulation, and grounding practices, it becomes easier to problem-solve, set boundaries, and practice assertiveness. For some, reconciliation may be possible later with appropriate support. For others, it may not. Do not let someone else’s refusal to engage in change hold you to ransom.

I offer telehealth appointments by video or phone, which can be especially helpful during periods like Christmas when family stress intensifies. You can also meet with me in Surry Hills in-person.


Support and Crisis Numbers (Australia)

If this topic has brought up distress or thoughts of harm, support is available.

Suicide and Crisis Support

Mental Health Support

Family and Domestic Violence Support